Apr 14, 2010
How to play the What If? game the right way
Right now, you’re playing the What If? game, and you’re playing it wrong.
You are never going to be able to go back and make different choices. As Daniel Faraday would remind you, whatever happened, happened. So stop fantasizing about scenarios in which the past 29 years might have turned out more artistically satisfying. More importantly, stop beating up the younger version of yourself. He wasn’t lazy or naive. He was you.
Here are your new rules for the What If? game:
- Only ask What If? questions about the future. What If you now devoted yourself full-time to writing? Or, What If you stopped carrying this torch for screenwriting, and pursued something else you enjoyed? Which would make you happier?
- Only think about the person you are today. A 20-year old has different options and challenges than a 49-year old. How much of your current life would you be willing to up-end?
- Recognize assumptions. Don’t assume you know where a path would take you. Rather, ask whether traveling that path would be interesting and fulfilling.
- via screenwriter John August










I’m always wondering, not so much what if, but when am I going to “make a difference” or “save this world”. I suppose it’s a little arrogant to think I’m going to do it, but honestly, what if I do!